Forget You Saw Her
- Judith D Collins
- 3 days ago
- 7 min read
Series: Ask for Andrea #.5
By: Noelle W. Ihli
Narrators: Andi Arndt, Carlotta Brentan, Brittany Pressley
Simon Maverick
ISBN: 9798992716108
Publisher: Dynamite Books
Publication Date: 11/04/2025
Format: Other
My Rating: 5 Stars (ARC)
She lost her daughter once.
Now, she’ll go to hell and back to find her.
Seventeen years ago, Sabina made the most difficult decision of her life: giving her newborn daughter, Andrea, up for adoption.
She’s lived with the guilt ever since, clinging to the hope that Andrea was safe, happy, and loved.
Then the letter from the police arrives. Andrea Beaumont is a missing person.
Desperate for answers, Sabina dives headlong into a frantic search for the daughter she never knew. But the deeper she digs, the more certain she becomes that Andrea isn’t coming home.
And yet … as Sabina follows the disturbing trail of evidence, she swears she can feel her daughter reaching through her dreams, warning her—and guiding her toward the truth.
But someone else is watching—and keeping close tabs on Sabina’s search. And they’ll do whatever it takes to make sure the truth stays buried.
Inspired by true events, Forget You Saw Her is a standalone prequel to the international bestseller Ask for Andrea.
FORGET YOU SAW HER #.5
About the Author
Noelle W. Ihli is an international bestselling author of thriller-suspense novels, including BookTok sensations Ask For Andrea and Run On Red. When she’s not plotting her next thriller, she’s scaring herself with true-crime documentaries or going for a trail ride in the foothills (with her trusty pepper spray)
Connect with the Author
Exceptional Authors.
Standout Books. Elevator Talk.
Behind the Book & the Author
INTRIGUING QUESTIONS. INQUIRING READERS WANT TO KNOW.
Welcome to the first (of three) featured November 2025 #LitLiftMiniAuthorChats a part of the #AuthorElevatorSeries with special guest author and favorite among thriller fans, Noelle W. Ihli and her electrifying new thriller, FORGET YOU SAW HER, a must-read prequel to her popular, ASK FOR ANDREA, out November 4, 2025.
Join us for a fun elevator ride and learn more about the book and this talented author!
Welcome, Noelle!
Behind the Book
Q. Give us your best ELEVATOR PITCH for FORGET YOU SAW HER.
Inspired by true events, Forget You Saw Her is about a birth mother’s desperate search to uncover what happened to the child she gave up for adoption—Andrea—who is now a missing person.
Q. DESCRIBE your novel in three words or fewer.
Emotional, suspenseful, fast-paced
Q. TOPICS: Name 1-3 topics or themes addressed in the novel?
Serial killers, grief, and courage
Q. DID YOU KNOW? Name 3-5 things that readers may (or may not know) about your book or series.
This book is a standalone prequel to my bestseller Ask for Andrea. I never intended to write more in this universe, even though it resonated deeply with readers.
But when I learned about Cathy Terkanian and her daughter (in the documentary Into the Fire), the heart-wrenching story got my wheels spinning—and I decided to write a book about Andrea herself.
For anyone who needs a reminder, “Ask for Andrea” is a code phrase that women are encouraged to use at a bar or restaurant if they don’t feel safe on a date/need help. Ironically, the book Ask for Andrea never answered the question of WHO Andrea was and how that campaign came about. Forget You Saw Her answers those questions!
Q. UPCOMING: Can you share what you are currently working on or what is next in ten words or less?
A survival thriller set on a remote stretch of the Salmon River :)
Behind the Author:
Q. DID YOU KNOW? Name 3-5 things that readers may (or may not know) about YOU, the author.
1. One time, my picture was on the front page of the Springfield Utah newspaper, for a cake-decorating competition.
2. The only animal I’m afraid of is spiders. I’ll happily pick up a snake.
3. I love adventure, and I’ve been skydiving, bungee jumping, spelunking, and paragliding.
Fascinating! Thank you, Noelle, for taking the time to speak with us today.
Join Noelle
Fall 2025
Ask For Andrea Tour!
My Review
Emotional. Haunting. Harrowing.
FORGET YOU SAW HER is an exhilarating standalone psychological thriller that also acts as a must-read prequel to Noelle W. Ihli's acclaimed work, "Ask for Andrea."
This captivating tale follows Sabina, a mother who faced the agonizing decision to place her daughter, Andrea, for adoption 17 years ago.
Now, with Andrea's sudden and mysterious disappearance, Sabina finds herself on a relentless journey to uncover the truth. As she delves deeper into her investigation, she uncovers disturbing revelations that shake her understanding of her daughter's past.
What makes this narrative even more compelling is its loose inspiration from real-life events, which adds an intriguing layer of authenticity to the unfolding drama.
About...
At just sixteen, Sabina faced an unimaginable situation when she became pregnant. Under pressure from her parents, she made the heart-wrenching decision to place her baby girl for adoption—a choice that has haunted her for the past seventeen years. With a heavy heart, she often reflects on that moment, feeling an enduring guilt and a lingering hope that her daughter might someday seek her out.
In the years that followed, Sabina found love and married an incredible man named Joel. Together, they dreamed of expanding their family, only to be met with the devastating news that she could not conceive again. The weight of her past decisions became even heavier as she pondered the life her daughter might have had with them, safe and loved. Who could have foreseen the tragic twists of fate that lay ahead?
Missing Daughter, Andrea...
Then, out of the blue, Sabina receives a chilling message from authorities: her biological daughter is missing. Without hesitation, she embarks on a grueling fifteen-hour drive to Utah, determined to help in the search. With Joe's support, they delve into a harrowing investigation that uncovers a sinister truth about the man and woman who adopted her daughter—a predator within the Mormon strict community, who has deceived many with his charm while hiding a dark reality. But how will they prove it?
The stakes are high, and the challenge is daunting. How can they gather the evidence needed to hold him accountable for her daughter’s disappearance—and for another girl whose story is equally tragic—when the consequences could be deadly?
As the investigation unfolds, Sabina finds herself on a perilous journey, feeling the presence of her daughter guiding her toward the truth. With unwavering determination and resilience, she is committed to uncovering the dark secrets that threaten their lives and will stop at nothing until justice is served for her daughter.
This gripping tale intertwines elements of psychological thriller, crime, and the supernatural, inviting readers into a world filled with suspense, danger, and the unbreakable bond of a mother’s love.
Genre: Psychological thriller. Crime. Serial Killer. Kidnapping. Supernatural.
My Reflections...
An emotional rollercoaster. You will be spellbound.
This captivating prequel serves as a powerful introduction to ASK FOR ANDREA, and I wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone seeking an absorbing, unsettling, yet gripping read.
Inspired by ...
FORGET YOU SAW HER immerses readers in the backstory of Andrea, drawing inspiration from the real-life experiences of Cathy Terkanian and her daughter Alexis, who was renamed Aundria Bowman after her adoption by Dennis and Brenda Bowman.
To enhance this narrative, I also viewed the Netflix documentary "Into the Fire," which serves as an essential companion to both the prequel and "ASK FOR ANDREA," intensifying its suspense and harrowing nature. Both narratives are truly spine-chilling! Fact and fiction, biological mothers share their tenacity, courage, and remarkable love for their daughters, and their determined efforts help solve the case and the murder of other victims.
Dark, terrifying, and suspenseful, the author masterfully delves into profound themes of motherhood, loss, adoption, and a mother's unwavering determination to find her child, even in the face of harrowing truths and hidden dangers.
The warnings received serve as a poignant and emotional validation of the mother-daughter bond. They reinforce Sabina's belief that their connection remains intact despite the adoption, empowering her in her perilous quest for answers. Andrea's ethereal warnings lead the path to justice following her ghostly guidance.
Yet, the sinister, shadowy figure of evil closely monitors Sabina's investigation, intent on keeping the truth about Andrea and other transgressions buried. This tension is heart-pounding, compelling you to turn the pages well into the night.
Ihli masterfully captures the universal horror of a loved one disappearing without a trace. Centered on the anguished biological mother, Sabina, and her desperate search for answers, resonates deeply with the experiences of countless families embroiled in missing person investigations.
Psychological and supernatural elements are expertly interwoven and explored, reminiscent of true crime documentaries and paranormal investigations.
Symbolism:
Monarch butterflies symbolize transformation, renewal, and the life cycle due to their metamorphosis, but they also represent hope, resilience, and perseverance, given their epic migrations, much like the strong women in the novel.
I wholeheartedly endorse this talented author and am eagerly diving into her remarkable collection of past works!
Audiobook...
As for the audiobook experience, I'm eager to immerse myself in the captivating narration by the brilliant Brittany Pressley, Andi Arndt, and Cotta Brentan.
Recs...
FORGET YOU SAW HER and ASK FOR ANDREA are must-reads for enthusiasts of the genre and true-crime, particularly those who appreciate the compelling narratives crafted by authors such as Karin Slaughter, Frieda McFadden, Lisa Jewell, Chevy Stevens, Clémence Michallon, Robyn Harding, Laura McHugh, Rebecca McKanna, Heather Gudenkauf, and Lisa Unger. Dive into these captivating thrillers and discover your next favorite read!
Many thanks to Victory Editing NetGalley Co-Op, Dynamite Books, and NetGalley for providing an advanced review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: Nov 4, 2025
My Rating: 5 Stars
